Skip to Content

Healthier Copycat Butterfinger Granola

This healthy granola recipe transforms rolled oats and puffed rice cereal into butterscotch, peanut butter, and chocolate coated crunchy goodness. Every serving has 5 grams of protein and just 13 grams of carbs. That’s roughly half the amount of carbs in traditional protein granola recipes! 

You'll love this crunchy butterscotch and peanut butter granola that's coated in melted chocolate! Every serving has 5 grams of protein and nearly half the carbs of traditional protein granola. Recipe includes a video tutorial, too!

This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualified sales. Click here to read my full disclosure.

Ingredients for Healthy Granola

This copycat Butterfinger granola is very similar to my chocolate peanut butter granola recipe. So if you’ve tried that one, you should have most of the ingredients on hand already. Most of the ingredients are straightforward enough, but I’ll briefly run through a few commonly asked about ingredients. 

Puffed Rice Cereal

I typically buy this ingredient in bulk from Amazon, but you might be able to find them in your grocery store around the gluten free cereals.

I have the brand I use on my Amazon foods list, if you’re interested. 

Honey and Liquid Egg Whites

If you’ve tried my cinnamon protein granola, you might be wondering whether or not honey can be swapped for a sugar free syrup like Walden Farms. I’ve tested this in my healthy granola recipes that call for honey and while it does work, the finished product tends to be a bit dry. 

I will say that the added chocolate post-baking in this Butterfinger granola could alleviate these issues. 

As for the egg whites, these are in the recipe to help the granola crisp without adding more calories from honey or peanut butter. You may be able to get away with more egg whites and less honey to reduce the carbs, but I haven’t tested it. 

chocolate peanut butter protein granola, cinnamon granola, and pumpkin spice low carb granola

You can get more ingredient swap ideas in my chocolate peanut butter and pumpkin spice granola recipes. 

Protein Powder

This healthy granola recipe calls for PEScience Select, a blend of whey and casein protein. The addition of casein makes the protein powder a bit thicker than a whey-only powder. 

Pro tip: You can order samples of PEScience if you’re new to recipes with protein powder. If you like it, you can use my affiliate discount code mason to save 15% off on PEScience products. And if you’re looking for other recipes to try with a sample pack, try my Butterfinger protein oats, no bake oatmeal peanut butter bites, or homemade McGriddles.

If you’re using a different protein, you may need to use a full two scoops or slightly more. I’ve added a video of the recipe below so you can get an idea of what the granola should look like before baking. 

Final Healthy Granola Recipe Notes

As with any protein powder recipe, you’re encouraged to stick to the recipe as closely as possible. If you make modifications, keep an even closer eye on the granola to avoid burning or over baking. 

To troubleshoot a soft granola, break it into smaller pieces and continue baking longer. If the granola burns before it’s crispy, you can try covering in foil to continue drying it out without charring. You can also try again with a lower temperature so it has time to dry out before burning. 

If you have ingredient or troubleshooting questions, you can drop a comment below or join my free Facebook group. There are nearly 10,000 people there to help you out! 

high protein butterfinger healthy granola recipe

Butterfinger Granola

Yield: 15 servings
Prep Time: 5 minutes
Cook Time: 20 minutes
Total Time: 25 minutes

Crunchy rolled oats and puffed rice cereal coated in butterscotch, peanut butter, and chocolate.

Ingredients

  • 1 C (80g) Rolled Oats
  • 2 C (34g) Puffed Rice Cereal
  • 1 1/2 scoop (47g) PEScience Protein Powder, vanilla
  • 2 Tbsp (16g) Sugar Free Butterscotch Pudding Mix
  • 1/3 C (87g) Creamy Peanut Butter
  • 2 Tbsp (42g) Honey
  • 1/3 C (81g) Liquid Egg Whites
  • 1/4 C (56g) Mini Chocolate Chips, I used Lakanto Sugar Free

Instructions

  1. Preheat an oven to 350F and line a baking sheet with parchment paper or nonstick spray.
  2. Mix the dry ingredients together in a large bowl before adding in the peanut butter and honey. Fold together until no lumps of peanut butter remain before adding the egg whites. Continue folding together until evenly mixed.
  3. Transfer the mixture to the baking sheet. Use a spatula to spread it evenly across the entire baking sheet. Be sure to break up any large clumps and aim to have as many holes or spaces as possible in the mixture.
  4. Bake for 15 minutes before removing from the oven to break up and flip on the baking sheet. Bake for an additional 6-10 minutes, shaking every 2-3 minutes until the granola is crispy. (The honey can burn so keep your eyes and nose peeled. It will continue to dry out/crisp once it’s out of the oven so don’t be afraid to pull it a little early.)
  5. Once the granola has slightly cooled and is as crispy as you like, add the chocolate chips and stir. They'll melt a bit and stick to the granola. Fully cool before storing in an airtight container (mason jars work great).

Notes

Each serving has 4 Smart Points.

Nutrition Information:
Yield: 15 Servings Serving Size: 1/4 C (23g)
Amount Per Serving: Calories: 105Total Fat: 4gCarbohydrates: 13gProtein: 5g

Want more kinda healthy recipes?

Follow me on Pinterest to see all of my recipes organized in one place with photos!

healthy baked orange chicken in a black bowl
Baked Orange Chicken
← Read Last Post
king ranch chicken casserole in a cast iron skillet with a slice on a black plate beside it
Healthy King Ranch Chicken Casserole
Read Next Post →

Katy K

Saturday 17th of April 2021

I love everything butter finger. Anything that is butterfinger I must have. I no longer buy granola. SO easy and flavorful!

Angie

Wednesday 15th of April 2020

Five stars! This has been a go to for me for at least a year. I use it with fresh berries in my yogurt every day. It’s my favorite mid morning treat! I double the recipe and it stores just fine for weeks in the pantry.

Dendy

Wednesday 15th of April 2020

Absolutely delicious! I made a double batch because I needed a sweet, chocolately snack. It only lasted 2 days! 10/10 will make again!

Rimma

Wednesday 29th of January 2020

This stuff definitely passes the crunch test! I am a granola feen and was so excited to see a higher protein version of it! Most important thing is to watch it while it bakes. Take it out too early and it wont be crunchy but if you leave it in too long it will start to crisp up and burn a bit.

Lindsey Goldman

Tuesday 26th of November 2019

My favorite Mason granola!! I used to buy those yogurt packs with the crunch toppings but now I'm making this granola for my yogurt. Oh and my kids have been eating it for breakfast!

Skip to Recipe