Skip to Content

Chocolate Peanut Butter Protein Pop Tarts

Okay, I promise this is the last protein pop tart I’ll make with the Kodiak Cakes pancake mix. But you know I couldn’t pass up the opportunity to use all three of the big flavors—buttermilk, dark chocolate, and crunchy peanut butter. If you haven’t seen my Everything Bagel Protein Pop Tarts, add them to the queue. These Chocolate Peanut Butter Protein Pop Tarts will be the last of this Kodiak Cakes recipe series, though I plan to make more protein pop tarts with other ingredients since people seem to be enjoying them.

This recipe follows the same strategy as the Hot Fudge Sundae version and makes three pop tarts instead of two huge pop tarts like the Everything Bagel version. The macros are very similar between the two chocolate versions, but this one comes in a tiny bit higher calorie thanks to three servings of chocolate chips used for the filling and frosting. You know what that means, right? They’re extra chocolatey and delicious.

Seriously, the level of chocolate in this recipe puts the real thing to shame.

chocolate peanut butter protein pop tart

This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualified sales. Click here to read my full disclosure.

Kodiak Cakes Recipe: How to Make Protein Pop Tarts

The pop tart dough itself doesn’t get much easier. Thanks to the Kodiak Cakes, all you’ll need is a bit of fat free Greek yogurt to make the dough. That’s it.

You can see the dough come together in the images below, and I’ve also included the video from my Everything Bagel version before the recipe card at the bottom of this post.

kodiak cakes recipe how to make chocolate peanut butter pop tarts

The biggest tip I can give is to make sure you continue working the dough. It will seem as if it’s too dry and needs more Greek yogurt, but it’s not. Just keep working and stirring and it will come together.

Also, you can see in the fifth image where there are leftover trimmings. This is for filling in gaps around the edges or tops to make sure your protein pop tarts are entirely enclosed. That said, the more even you can get your dough when rolling the better. That will give you the most even finished product.

Chocolate Protein Pop Tart Filling and Frosting

For the protein pop tart filling and frosting, it’s almost as easy as the dough. You’ll need to melt down some chocolate chips and mix them with a bit of almond milk (or your choice of liquid), protein powder, and cocoa powder. I always use vanilla protein powder and add cocoa powder (flavor and multi-purpose use of vanilla protein vs chocolate preferences) but if you want to just use chocolate protein powder, that’s totally fine.

chocolate peanut butter protein pop tart frosting

Final Notes and Other Kodiak Cakes Recipe Ideas

The video below from my Everything Bagel Protein Pop Tarts should give you a great idea of how to assemble and use leftover trimmings from the pop tart dough. Remember, the Everything Bagel version makes two huge pop tarts where this chocolate peanut butter version makes three.

All right, that’s all ya need to know. I hope you enjoy your protein pop tarts!

Beyond my other protein pop tarts recipes, I recommend checking out the recipe section of the Kodiak Cakes site. They publish great content and plenty of new ideas to make using their products.

kodiak cakes recipe chocolate peanut butter protein pop tarts

Chocolate Peanut Butter Protein Pop Tarts

Yield: 3 Pop Tarts
Prep Time: 15 minutes
Cook Time: 12 minutes
Total Time: 27 minutes

A super simple Kodiak Cakes recipe that's loaded with chocolate, protein, and satisfaction. 


Peanut Butter Protein Pop Tart

Protein Pop Tart Filling and Frosting

  • 3 Tbsp (42g) Dark Chocolate Chips, 70 cals per Tbsp
  • 2-3 Tbsp (30-45mL) Unsweetened Almond Milk
  • 1/2 scoop (16g) Protein Powder, vanilla
  • 1 Tbsp (5g) Unsweetened Dark Cocoa Powder


  1. Preheat an oven to 350F and line a baking sheet with parchment paper.
  2. Mix the pancake mix and Greek yogurt in a large bowl. Work the dough until you can form one large ball.
  3. Transfer the dough to the baking sheet and use a rolling pin or the backside of a spatula to flatten the dough. (Spray with nonstick cooking spray to alleviate any sticking issues.) You want the dough to take up most of the baking sheet. Use a knife or pizza cutter to trim the edges and create 4-6 squares in the center of the dough.
  4. You may have to re-roll trimmings to form all 6. And after you've formed all 6, you'll still have a few leftover trimmings. Save those for filling in gaps and edges. 
  5. Microwave the chocolate chips in a small bowl for 45-60 seconds or until you can stir them into smooth chocolate. Add the almond milk, protein powder, and cocoa powder. The 2-3 tablespoon range will depend on the consistency of your protein powder. Start with 2 and if it's too thick, add more. (Note: as the chocolate cools, it will thicken even further.)
  6. Spoon about 2/3 of the chocolate mixture onto three of the pop tart squares. The remaining chocolate will be your frosting. 
  7. Once the filling is in place, enclose the pop tarts with the remaining squares. Use the remaining trimmings to fill in any edges that need extra dough. Use a fork to crimp the edges to ensure the filling stays in place in the oven.
  8. Bake for 12 minutes.
  9. Remove to cool briefly before adding the remaining chocolate. Top with sprinkles, crushed nuts or cereal (like Reese's Puffs), or nothing at all. Be sure to include any toppings in your macros if you're tracking. Refrigerate leftovers.


  • Each one has 10 Smart Points.
  • I always use vanilla protein powder and add cocoa powder (flavor and multi-purpose use of vanilla protein vs chocolate preferences) but if you want to just use chocolate protein powder, that's totally fine. 
  • If you'd like to reduce the calories and carbs, you could pull back to one tablespoon of chocolate chips and use a Greek yogurt mixture to bulk up the filling. The top icing from my Hot Fudge Sundae protein pop tarts would be great (it's comprised of Greek yogurt and cocoa powder only). 
Nutrition Information:
Yield: 3 Pop Tarts Serving Size: 1 Pop Tart
Amount Per Serving: Calories: 323Total Fat: 8gCarbohydrates: 43gProtein: 23g

Want more kinda healthy recipes?

Follow me on Pinterest to see all of my recipes organized in one place with photos!

When you try this Kodiak Cakes recipe or any of my protein pop tarts recipe and dig ’em, I wanna hear about it. Take a picture of your creation and tag me on Instagram and I’ll be sure to share it with the world! Or if you’re more active on Pinterest, I’d appreciate you pinning this recipe. K, thanks for reading!

A simple, 6-ingredient Kodiak Cakes recipe for chocolate peanut butter protein pop tarts. You'll never believe each pop tart has 23 grams of protein.

Brad S

Friday 1st of May 2020

I tried it inverted (dark chocolate Kodiak Cakes with peanut butter frosting/filling). I used Reese's baking chips and PB2 instead of the chocolate chips and normal protein powder. They turned out alittle chewy so next time I'll maybe try to flatten them out more or cook for a couple more minutes. Delicious though!

Maria W

Wednesday 15th of April 2020

Yum! I thought I had thrown away my peanut butter Kodiak mix because I didn’t like it when made as directed, but when I rediscovered it in my pantry I knew I had to make these. Great way to salvage an initially disappointing mix!

Sarah Ruddle

Sunday 24th of November 2019

Mine looked half as good as Mason’s but did taste amazing and were great stored in the fridge and reheated the next morning in a toaster oven.

Brianna Bliss

Sunday 24th of November 2019

LOVED this recipe. I’ve learned to use the recipient and mic and match ingredients because I do love me some pop tarts! However I will be getting retting for prep season soon...can’t wait to make these again to fit into my macros!


Wednesday 26th of June 2019

Omg you should try these with Hiit nutrition’s brownie batter stuffed inside, that’d be even easier and yummier! I put it in crepes and waffles so I imagine it’d be just as delicious! Also, I’m allergic to every single one of kodiaks products, do you have a recommendation for an alternative??

Mason Woodruff

Thursday 27th of June 2019

You could try them with Bisquick or Carbquick. I've seen lots of folks use them interchangeably in my cinnamon roll in a mug recipe.

Skip to Recipe