Buffalo Chicken Mac and Cheese

This buffalo chicken mac and cheese combines ground chicken with healthier chickpea pasta, a low fat buffalo cheese sauce, and bubbly monterey jack cheese. Each serving has 34 grams of protein with just 31 grams of carbs, and you should be able to have dinner on the table in about 30 minutes.

I’ll walk you through the full recipe below and cover ingredient substitutions and tips for cooking as we go. You can find a printable recipe card at the bottom of the post if you’re familiar with my recipes and ready to get cracking!

Cook your choice of macaroni in salted water.

Any type of pasta will work here, but I’m a fan of Banza’s chickpea pasta. It’s higher in protein and fiber, gluten free, and has great texture and flavor. I’ve used it in everything from my chicken fajita pasta bake to queso mac and cheese with chipotle ground beef.

The only tip I have for this step would be to avoid cooking your pasta too early. The recipe calls for cooking it just shy of al dente, about 5 minutes. If you need to prep ingredients or work slowly, maybe hold off adding the pasta to the water until you have the ground chicken cooked.

Cook ground chicken with diced onion and minced garlic.

Speaking of cooking ground chicken, this step is straightforward enough. You can omit the onion if you have picky eaters around, but the serving sizes may be slightly affected. And since the onion will release some moisture as it cooks, you may need to use a bit of olive oil for cooking the chicken.

If you’d rather use chicken breast, you could make the chicken from my shredded buffalo chicken nachos recipe.

(Optional) Add ranch seasoning.

Since you already have two major flavor components of ranch—garlic and onion—in the mix, I’ve listed this ingredient as optional. It adds a hints of buttermilk, dill, and saltiness. But the buffalo sauce is plenty salty, so you can just salt to taste before topping with shredded cheese at the end.

Add buffalo sauce. 

I used the same Frank’s RedHot sauce that I used for my buffalo air fryer tuna cakes and 45-calorie buffalo chicken bites. If you wanted to make your own, here’s a recipe for homemade buffalo sauce from Mike at Chili Pepper Madness.

Since the recipe doesn’t call for any oil, you may have some sticky bits depending on the cookware you use. The buffalo sauce should help deglaze the pan to get those off before reducing the heat.

Mix fat free Greek yogurt with cheddar powder and add to the cooked buffalo chicken.

What is cheddar powder? 

If you’re unfamiliar with recipes like my 30-minute cheeseburger soup or air fried cheesy potatoes, cheddar powder is essentially dehydrated cheddar cheese. Think: powdered peanut butter.

You can use cheddar powder as a dry ingredient or seasoning, but my favorite way to use it is reconstituting in some kind of liquid for sauces like the cheese sauce for this buffalo chicken mac and cheese. It makes a creamy cheese sauce with a fraction of the fat and calories of traditional cheese sauces.

Where to buy cheddar powder 

Your best bet is to order some on Amazon (I’ve included it on my recommended ingredients Amazon list). Some specialty stores may carry it but if you’re in a pinch, you can steal a package from other boxed mac and cheese.

Don’t want to use cheddar powder? Check out the blended cottage cheese sauce in my high protein mac n cheese.

Add the cooked pasta and fold everything together.

If you’re using chickpea pasta, you’ll want to go straight from draining to the pan as it can stick together a bit as it cools to room temp. You can toss drained pasta in a little olive oil to help prevent this if your timing is off.

And if you love this buffalo ground chicken and wanted something else to use it for, you could plug it into my buffalo chicken stuffed peppers recipe.

Top with freshly grated cheese and broil ’til bubbly. 

The recipe calls for monterey jack, but you can use mozzarella or any softer melting cheese. I’ve honestly never broiled blue cheese, but I’m guessing that’d be a fine substitute.

Top with some green onion and you’re ready to rock!

If you have any questions about this buffalo chicken mac and cheese, feel free to leave a comment or join my Facebook group. There are more than 14,000 healthy home cooks in the group to help out!