Creamy Buffalo Ground Chicken Chili

This high protein ground chicken chili combines fresh vegetables and herbs with a creamy buffalo sauce. It’s super filling and satisfies the buffalo chicken cravings. There are also options for dairy free and picky eater friendly versions, making it a great weeknight dinner option in a pinch.

How to Make Creamy Buffalo Chili with Ground Chicken

This is a super easy recipe, but I’ve included a visual recipe walkthrough with extra notes on ingredient substitutions, the picky eater version, and general prep tips in the post below. You’ll find a full recipe card at the bottom of the post as well.

1. Brown ground chicken on both sides and add diced onion and celery.

Like I mentioned in my recent ground chicken Dan Dan Noodles recipe, patting the chicken dry with a paper towel, making sure the pot and oil are both really hot before adding the chicken, and exercising patience are all key to successfully browning meat. You are after the golden brown color on both sides, as that creates tons of flavor.

Also, if you’re a fellow central or south Texan, HEB sells pre-diced onion and celery together in the perfect ratios for this ground chicken chili. Not saying that’s what I used to save time. Wink wink.

2. Add chili beans, buffalo sauce, seasoning, and chicken broth.

You’ll find some substitution notes for the seasoning and herbs in the picky eater version below. For the buffalo sauce, I always use Frank’s RedHot buffalo sauce. Since this recipe has a dairy free option, I’ll point out that Frank’s has non-dairy butter flavor, not actual butter in its ingredients. You can also make homemade buffalo sauce.

Want more things to make with buffalo sauce? Check out my Instant Pot buffalo chicken dip and buffalo chicken stuffed peppers.

3. Bring to a boil before reducing to a simmer for about 20 minutes.

You want your ground chicken chili to thicken a bit and have plenty of time for the flavors to get to know one another. The onion and celery should be completely softened and nearly indistinguishable as well.

If you’re using a pressure cooker, I would go with something like 15-20 minutes on high pressure. You can always add a bit more broth at the end if your chili is too thick.

4. Turn off the heat and stir in cream cheese before serving.

At the request of many readers and a personal curiosity, I’ve started testing dairy free cheese options. Kite Hill seems to be the most popular suggestion in reader polls for the best dairy free substitutes. I used their regular and chive cream cheese in test batches and was quite surprised at how creamy and smooth it is.

Is real cream cheese better? You bet. Will you notice a huge difference in the finished product using something like Kite Hill? No.

All that said, if you’re good with dairy, cheese it up and thank your lucky stars! You can also use another dairy free thickener in chopped corn tortillas. Check out my White Bean Ground Chicken Soup for an example.

For Picky Eater Approved Ground Chicken Chili

One of my wife’s favorite recipes ever is a buffalo chicken chili I developed for Stronger U during my tenure as their Food Dude. It was a very basic slow cooker chili with chicken breast, buffalo sauce, ranch seasoning, beans, and cream cheese. I developed this recipe with that in mind, hoping to add some fresh ingredients, ground chicken, and have a dairy free option.

But if you want to appease the picky eater in your house, you can omit the onion and celery. My wife is fine with fresh parsley but you could cut that out, too. So you would brown the ground chicken, break it apart, season with about a tablespoon of ranch seasoning, and add the remaining ingredients. In case you need it, you can make your own dairy free ranch seasoning.

Serving Your Creamy Buffalo Chicken Chili

Green onion, chives, or more fresh parsley are a great topping. And a dollop of fat free Greek yogurt or light sour cream add some great acidity to balance the creamy buffalo sauce.

Sticking with the dairy free theme, Siete makes a non-dairy, grain-free ranch flavored chip that’s really solid. But one thing about buffalo is that it goes with just about anything. Tortilla chips, crackers, pita chips, you name it—this chili will be a good fit. To take it up a notch, you could make garlic bread or some of my air fryer cheesy bread.

If you need something to round out a full meal, you could always go the sandwich route. Since this is a very hearty, meaty chili, you might go with something like a grilled cheese or this grilled vegetable and cheese sandwich.

More Healthy Soup and Chili Recipes

Okay, that’s all you need to know about this buffalo ground chicken chili. Before you go, I’ll leave you with a handful of recipes that are perfect for soup season.

• Creamy Taco Soup
• Ground Chicken Chili
• Instant Pot Turkey Chili
• Air Fryer Roasted Butternut Squash Soup
• Mexican Chicken Soup
• Slow Cooker Texas Chili

If you have a question about this recipe I forgot to cover, you can leave it in the comments below. And recipe reviews are always appreciated!