High Protein Chocolate Pie Recipe and Bonus Microwaveable Pie Recipe
This post may contain affiliate links. Click here to read my full disclosure.
Don’t let pie fool you into thinking these take a ton of skill or time. In reality, this protein chocolate pie is super easy to make. The oven baked version takes 10-15 minutes and the microwave version will be down the hatch in that time.
And the ingredients? You’ll only need four things.
If you haven’t tried the cherry pie recipe yet, consider throwing it in the mix as it’s the tastiest of the mini protein pies, in my opinion.
Chocolate Protein Pie Ingredients
Below you’ll see the mini pie crusts I used. You can find a recipe below to make your own and even a microwaveable version. If you’d like to use a full-size, reduced fat graham cracker crust, the calories/macros should turn out to be very close.
You can find these on Amazon here.
A quick note I’d give on the fat-free evaporated milk is to be sure to avoid any fat-free version that still has 100+ calories per serving. Several replace the fat with sugar and the calories remain the same. I use Nestle Carnation which has 25 calories per serving (30mL). Update: I found a comparable generic product at Kroger.
If you don’t have any fat-free sugar-free pudding mix on hand, you could use unsweetened cocoa powder (gram for gram) and a 1/2 Tbsp of stevia instead. Or worst case, you could just go with protein and evaporated milk. If you go this route, you’ll likely want to add a bit more protein to keep the mixture thick.
Best Protein Powder for Recipes
You can use any protein you’d like. I find that a vanilla protein with added cocoa gives a better chocolate taste, but you could just use chocolate protein and omit the cocoa if you like. As for protein recommendations, I go with Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard Whey and/or Dymatize’s Whey or Elite XT blended protein. They’re reputable brands that have been around forever.
The macros in both recipes are with Gold Standard Whey.
If you’d like to learn more about the different types of whey protein and how to find the best value for protein, read this article.
Chocolate Protein Pie
A high protein chocolate pie that's under 300 calories and tastes fantastic.
- 2 Tbsp (30mL) Fat-Free Evaporated Milk
- 1 scoop (30g) Protein Powder chocolate
- 1 serving (10g) Fat-Free Sugar-Free Pudding Mix chocolate
- 1 mini Keebler Ready Graham Cracker Crust or make your own
Preheat oven to 375 degrees F.
Mix all ingredients in a bowl and add to crust.
Bake pie crust(s) and filling on top of a baking sheet for 10 minutes. If you only prepare one pie at a time, you'll want to reduce the cook time. For this pie, you want the center to be almost cooked through but slightly gooey.
275 Calories | 27P | 27C | 6F
If you’d like to make your own crust and shorten the cook time with a microwave, check out the recipe below. You’ll use the same process and cook time for the crust – just use the filling recipe from above.
High Protein Cherry Pie (Microwave)
A high protein pie with fewer than 250 calories and ready in less than 5 minutes.
- 1/2 serving (13g) Graham Cracker Crumbles
- 1 Tbsp (15g) Unsweetened Apple Sauce use 2 Tbsp if dry after cooking
- 2/3 C (170g) Sugar-Free Cherry Pie Filling
- 1 scoop Protein Powder vanilla
Spray a small bowl or mug with nonstick cooking spray.
Mix graham cracker crumbles and apple sauce together in the bottom of the bowl or mug. Using your fingers or the backside of a spoon, flatten the mixture into a crust.
In a separate bowl, mix cherry pie filling and protein.
Add pie mixture to mug on top of the crust.
Microwave in 30-second intervals (to avoid overflow) for 90-120 seconds or until pie center looks firm.
243 Calories | 24P | 29C | 2F --- You can add a second tablespoon of apple sauce to your crust if you find it tough after cooking. Some pie fillings cook faster depending on the bowl you use and ingredients in the filling.
If you’re looking for another microwaveable protein pie idea, I have a blueberry protein pie recipe that uses fresh or frozen blueberries. Check it out!
And as always, if you make this for a post-workout snack or sweets fix, tag me in your creation on Instagram.
And if you’re looking for more high protein chocolate recipes, you’ll love my free cookbook for chocolate lovers. You can check it out here or enter your info below to download a copy.